Car Loan vs Lease: How to Choose
Leasing costs less per month; buying leaves you with a car that still has value. On a $42,000 car over 36 months, leasing costs $21,599 and buying costs $27,781.85 — but the buyer keeps $4,900.73 of equity and the lessee keeps nothing. This guide compares both on the same car, step by step.
By Jacob Levy, Founder of FigureQuick.com · Last reviewed 2026-11-19
Buying and leasing are not the same purchase
Buying a car means paying off a loan and ending up with an asset. Leasing a car means paying for the value the car loses while it is driven, and handing it back at the end. The monthly payment is lower on a lease because the payments only cover part of the car's value — the depreciation — while a loan payment covers the whole price plus interest. Comparing the two monthly payments is therefore not a comparison at all: it compares paying for part of a car against paying for all of it.
The honest comparison prices both over the same period, on the same car, and counts what is left at the end. The net cost of buying over the lease term is the down payment, plus the loan payments, minus the equity left in the car. The net cost of leasing is the cash due at signing, plus the lease payments, plus the lease-end fee. Whichever net cost is lower wins on money — and the equity is the whole difference. The Car Lease vs Buy Calculator runs that comparison from the price, down payment, APR, loan term, lease payment, lease term, and expected resale value, and the Complete Guide to Auto Loans, Leases, and Car Costs explains the loan and lease formulas behind it.
How a lease payment is built
A lease payment has two parts. The depreciation fee is (capitalized cost − residual value) / term in months: the value the car loses, spread over the lease. The finance fee is (capitalized cost + residual value) × money factor: the cost of borrowing the car's value while it is leased. The capitalized cost is the price the lease is based on, after any down payment or trade-in credit. The residual value is what the leasing company expects the car to be worth when the lease ends. The money factor is the lease version of an interest rate, entered as a small decimal.
On a $30,000 car with an $18,000 residual value, a money factor of 0.0025, and a 36-month term, the depreciation fee is ($30,000 − $18,000) / 36 = $333.33 a month, and the finance fee is ($30,000 + $18,000) × 0.0025 = $120.00 a month, for a monthly lease payment of $453.33 before tax. A higher residual value lowers the payment, because less value is lost; a higher money factor raises it, because borrowing costs more. The Auto Lease Payment Calculator splits the payment into its two parts for any capitalized cost, residual value, money factor, and term.
The money factor converts to an approximate APR by multiplying by 2,400. A money factor of 0.0025 is roughly a 6.0% APR. That conversion is the quickest way to judge a lease offer: if the equivalent APR is far above the APR on a loan for the same car, the lease is expensive borrowing dressed up as a low payment. Dealers quote the money factor, not the APR, which is why the conversion matters.
The 36-month comparison, worked out
Worked example: a $42,000 car over 36 months. Take a $42,000 car, $3,500 due at signing, a purchase loan at 6.49% APR over 60 months, a lease offer of $489 a month for 36 months, and an expected resale value of 55% of the price after three years. The purchase loan finances $41,440 — the price plus 7% sales tax, minus the $3,500 down payment — and the monthly loan payment is $810.63. After 36 payments the loan balance is $18,199.27, and the car is worth 55% of $42,000, which is $23,100, so the buyer holds $4,900.73 of equity. The net cost of buying over 36 months is $3,500 + (36 × $810.63) − $4,900.73 = $27,781.85. The net cost of leasing is $3,500 + (36 × $489) + a $495 lease-end fee = $21,599. Leasing costs $6,182.85 less over three years, but the buyer walks away with a car worth $23,100 and the lessee walks away with nothing. The Car Lease vs Buy Calculator reproduces this comparison exactly.
Notice what the monthly payments hide. The loan payment of $810.63 is $321.63 a month more than the lease payment of $489, yet the true gap over three years is only $6,182.85 — because $4,900.73 of the buyer's payments became equity instead of expense. A driver who sells the car after three years recovers that equity; a driver who keeps it longer recovers more, because the loan ends and the payments stop while the car keeps running. The lease payments never stop: the next lease starts where the last one ended.
Use this calculator with clients → White-label.
Four questions that decide it
First, how long will the car be kept? A driver who keeps cars for ten years will almost always spend less buying, because the loan is paid off in five years and the next five are payment-free. A driver who wants a new car every three years will usually spend less leasing, and pays for the privilege of never owning one. Second, how many miles a year? Leases carry mileage limits, commonly 10,000 to 12,000 miles a year, with a charge per mile over the limit. A high-mileage driver can wipe out the lease's saving in excess-mileage charges alone. Third, what is the resale value? A car that holds its value favours buying, because the equity at the end is larger; a car that loses value fast favours leasing, because the leasing company takes the depreciation risk. Fourth, what is the money factor? A lease at an equivalent APR far above the loan APR is expensive borrowing, and the low monthly payment is the thing that hides it.
There is also the question of what happens at the end. A buyer can sell, trade in, or keep driving. A lessee must return the car, pay the lease-end fee, and settle any charges for excess mileage or wear beyond what the lease allows — or buy the car for its residual value, which is the price set when the lease was signed, not the price the car is worth then. None of those are traps, but all of them are costs, and all of them belong in the comparison before the choice is made.
Cash back or low interest: the same choice in disguise
Dealers often offer a choice that looks like a bonus: take a cash-back rebate and finance at the regular rate, or skip the rebate and finance at a low promotional rate. It is the same kind of comparison as lease vs buy — two offers that sound different but can be priced on the same car. Take a $30,000 car over five years: with a $2,000 rebate at 6%, the amount financed is $28,000, the payment is $541.32 a month, and the total paid is $32,479.11. With 0% financing, the amount financed is the full $30,000, the payment is $500.00 a month, and the total paid is $30,000.00. The low-interest offer wins by $2,479.11 — the rebate is worth less than the interest it costs. That result flips when the rebate is bigger or the rate gap is smaller, which is why the choice cannot be made by rule of thumb. The Cash-Back or Low-Interest Calculator prices both offers from the vehicle price, rebate, both rates, and the term.
Sources and methodology
All worked-example arithmetic uses the standard amortisation formula for the loan and the depreciation-plus-finance formula for the lease, computed in Python and checked against the calculators named in the text. Interest rates (6.49%, 6%, 0%), the fuel price, and the resale value of 55% after three years are labelled example assumptions, not current market figures. The lease vs buy comparison bakes in a 7% sales tax on the financed amount and a $495 lease-end fee, as its calculator does. This guide is educational: it describes what the calculators compute, not advice about whether to lease or buy. Last reviewed 2026-11-19.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to lease or buy a car?
Over 36 months on a $42,000 car, leasing at $489 a month costs $21,599 in total, while buying costs $27,781.85 — but the buyer ends up with $4,900.73 of equity in the car and the lessee ends up with none. Leasing is cheaper per month; buying is cheaper once the equity is counted. A lease vs buy calculator compares both on the same car.
How is a lease payment calculated?
A lease payment has two parts: the depreciation fee, (capitalized cost - residual value) / term in months, and the finance fee, (capitalized cost + residual value) x money factor. On a $30,000 car with an $18,000 residual value, a 0.0025 money factor, and a 36-month term, the payment is $333.33 + $120.00 = $453.33 a month before tax.
What is a money factor, and how does it compare to an APR?
The money factor is the lease version of an interest rate. Multiply it by 2,400 for the approximate APR: a money factor of 0.0025 is roughly 6.0% APR. If the equivalent APR is far above the APR on a loan for the same car, the lease is expensive borrowing dressed up as a low payment.
When does leasing make sense?
Leasing makes sense when the monthly payment matters most, the car is driven within the mileage limit, and a new car every few years is the priority. It makes less sense for high-mileage drivers, for anyone who keeps cars a long time, and for anyone who wants to own an asset at the end. The deciding numbers are the resale value, the money factor, and the mileage limit.
