How Homeowners Insurance Is Calculated
Homeowners insurance is calculated from the cost of rebuilding the home, not from what it would sell for. Dwelling coverage is the home's size times the local rebuild cost per square foot — 2,200 sq ft at $195 a square foot is $429,000 — and every other coverage is a percentage of that figure. This guide works out each one.
By Jacob Levy, Founder of FigureQuick.com · Last reviewed 2026-11-19
Start with the rebuild cost, not the market value
The most important distinction in homeowners insurance is between market value and replacement cost. Market value is what the house would sell for, and it includes the land. Replacement cost is what it would cost to rebuild the house, and it excludes the land. Coverage A, the dwelling coverage, is based on replacement cost. Insuring for market value is the most common sizing mistake in homeowners insurance, and it leaves the home either under-insured or over-insured by the price of the land.
Dwelling coverage is the home's size times the local rebuild cost per square foot. The size is the heated living area, in square feet. The rebuild cost per square foot is what local builders charge to rebuild a home of the same quality, and it moves with labour and material prices in the area. The Homeowners Insurance Calculator works out the dwelling coverage from those two inputs, and the Complete Guide to Insurance: Life and Homeowners Coverage explains the coverages alongside life insurance.
The coverages, one by one
A standard homeowners policy, the HO-3 form used for most owner-occupied homes, is divided into sections, each with its own limit. Coverage A is the dwelling: the cost of rebuilding the house itself. Coverage B is other structures: detached garages, sheds, and fences. Coverage C is personal property: furniture, clothing, electronics, and everything else inside the home. Coverage D is loss of use: the extra cost of living elsewhere while the home is repaired. Personal liability, a separate limit, pays if someone is hurt on the property or the policyholder is found liable for damage to someone else.
Coverage A is the foundation, because the other limits are usually set as percentages of it. Personal property is commonly 50% of the dwelling limit, other structures 10%, and loss of use 20%. Those percentages are the calculator's defaults and the common policy defaults, but they can be changed: a home full of expensive contents needs more than 50%, and a home with no detached structures needs less than 10%. The liability limit is chosen separately, usually $300,000, $500,000, or $1,000,000.
The worked example
Worked example: a 2,200 sq ft home at $195 a square foot. Take a home with 2,200 square feet of heated living area and a local construction rebuild cost of $195 per square foot, with other structures at 10% of dwelling, personal property at 50%, and a $1,000 deductible. Dwelling Coverage A is 2,200 × $195 = $429,000. Personal Property Coverage C is 50% of that, which is $214,500. Other structures are 10%, which is $42,900. Loss of use is 20%, which is $85,800. The 80% co-insurance minimum, explained below, is $343,200. The estimated annual premium from the calculator's model is $1,780.35 a year. The Homeowners Insurance Calculator reproduces this example exactly.
Worked example: a smaller home with a higher deductible. Take a home with 1,800 square feet at a rebuild cost of $175 per square foot, with the same 50% personal property, and a $2,500 deductible. Dwelling Coverage A is 1,800 × $175 = $315,000. Personal Property Coverage C is $157,500. The 80% minimum is $252,000. The estimated annual premium is $1,124.23 a year — more than a third below the first example, showing how much of the premium is driven by the rebuild cost and the deductible rather than by the home's market price.
The premium figures in these examples come from the calculator's own illustrative model — $4.15 per $1,000 of dwelling coverage, adjusted by the deductible — not from an insurer's rates. A real premium depends on location, the home's age and construction, the claims history, and the insurer, and it can only come from a quote. The model's purpose is to show how the premium moves when the inputs change, not to predict what any insurer will charge.
The 80% rule
Most standard homeowners policies carry an 80% co-insurance rule: the home must be insured for at least 80% of its replacement cost for a partial loss to be paid in full. On a home with a $429,000 rebuild cost, the minimum is 80% of $429,000, which is $343,200. Insure for $343,200 or more and a partial loss is paid in full, up to the limit. Insure for less and the claim is paid proportionally.
The proportional payment is where the rule bites. Suppose the home above is insured for $300,000, about 70% of its replacement cost, and a fire causes $50,000 of damage. The insurer pays roughly 70% of the loss, or about $35,000, and the policyholder covers the remaining $15,000 — on top of the deductible. Rebuilding costs rise over time, which is why policies usually include an inflation guard that raises the dwelling limit each year, and why the limit deserves a check after a renovation or a sharp rise in local building costs.
Use this calculator with clients → White-label.
How the deductible changes the premium
Raising a deductible trades a small certain saving for a larger possible bill. The premium falls because the insurer takes less risk; the out-of-pocket cost on a claim rises because the policyholder takes more. Take a current policy with a $500 deductible and a $2,100 annual premium, against a proposed policy with a $1,000 deductible and a $1,760 annual premium, and liquid emergency savings of $5,000. The annual premium saving is $340. The extra out-of-pocket risk is $500 per claim. The break-even is $500 / $340 = 1.47 years, or 18 claim-free months. Over five claim-free years the net saving is $1,700. The Insurance Deductible Calculator reproduces this example exactly, including the 18-month break-even and the $1,700 five-year saving.
The deductible decision is really a savings decision. A higher deductible is only a good trade if the extra amount can be paid from savings on the day a claim happens. A household without that cushion is better off with the lower deductible and the higher premium, because the premium is a planned expense and the deductible is a surprise one. The calculator also checks whether the emergency savings are at least twice the proposed deductible — in the example, $5,000 of savings comfortably covers the $1,000 deductible twice over.
What moves the premium
Premiums move with the size of the loss being insured and with the likelihood of it happening. The drivers are the rebuild cost, the coverage limits, the deductible, the location, and the home itself: its age, its construction, its roof, and its claims history. Location matters more than most people expect: a home in an area with frequent storms, wildfires, or flooding costs more to insure than an identical home elsewhere. Some risks are excluded from a standard policy altogether — flood damage, for example, is generally not covered by a standard homeowners policy and needs separate cover.
One factor is fully in the policyholder's control: the amount of cover. Over-insuring wastes premium on cover that can never be collected, because the payout is capped at the loss. Under-insuring saves premium but leaves the loss partly unpaid, and it can trigger the 80% rule as well. The right amount is the loss itself — the rebuild cost — and the calculator exists to work that number out before a price is quoted.
Common mistakes
The most common mistake is insuring the home for its market value instead of its rebuild cost, which leaves it under-insured or over-insured by the price of the land. The second is letting the dwelling limit drift below the 80% minimum as building costs rise, and discovering the gap at claim time. The third is choosing a deductible from the premium alone, without checking whether the savings could cover it. The fourth is comparing premiums for different amounts of cover, which is not a comparison at all. Run the numbers, check the 80% minimum, and the cover follows.
Sources and methodology
Homeowners coverages follow the standard HO-3 policy structure described by the Insurance Information Institute (iii.org, 2025), including the 80% co-insurance rule. Premium figures are the calculator's illustrative model — $4.15 per $1,000 of dwelling coverage, adjusted by deductible ($500: 1.12; $1,000: 1.00; $2,500: 0.86; $5,000: 0.78) — not insurer quotes. All worked-example arithmetic was computed with the calculators' formulas and checked in Python. This guide is educational: it describes what the calculators compute, not advice about which policy or amount of cover to choose. Last reviewed 2026-11-19.
Frequently asked questions
How is homeowners insurance calculated?
Dwelling coverage is the home's size times the local rebuild cost per square foot: 2,200 sq ft at $195 a square foot is $429,000. Personal property is usually a percentage of that figure, often 50%, and other structures and loss of use are further percentages. The premium is then set from the coverage, the deductible, and the home's location and features.
How much is homeowners insurance?
It depends on the rebuild cost of the home, the coverage limits, the deductible, and the location. As an illustration from the calculator's own model, a 2,200 sq ft home at a $195 rebuild cost per square foot has $429,000 of dwelling coverage and an estimated premium of $1,780.35 a year with a $1,000 deductible. That is a model estimate, not a quote — a real premium comes from an insurer.
What is the 80% rule in homeowners insurance?
Most standard homeowners policies require the home to be insured for at least 80% of its replacement cost to pay a partial loss in full. On a home with a $429,000 rebuild cost, the minimum is $343,200. Insure below that and a partial claim is paid proportionally, so a $50,000 repair could be settled for less than $50,000.
How does a higher deductible change the premium?
Raising the deductible lowers the premium, because the insurer takes less risk. Moving from a $500 deductible at $2,100 a year to a $1,000 deductible at $1,760 a year saves $340 a year but adds $500 of risk per claim, and the saving covers the extra risk after 18 claim-free months. Over five claim-free years the net saving is $1,700.
