How to Evaluate a Rental Property
To evaluate a rental property, compare the rent with the price, work out the net operating income after expenses, and test whether the monthly cash flow is positive. A $220,000 property renting for $1,800 a month fails the 1% rule and produces only $62.25 a month of cash flow — this guide shows how each of those numbers is worked out.
By Jacob Levy, Founder of FigureQuick.com · Last reviewed 2026-11-19
Step 1: Start with the rent — the 1% rule
The first check is the relationship between the rent and the price. The 1% rule is a screening rule of thumb: the monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price. On a $200,000 property, that means $2,000 a month in rent; on a $300,000 property, $3,000. It is a quick filter for whether a property is worth a closer look, not a guarantee of cash flow. A property that passes the rule still needs a full cash flow check, and a property that fails it can still work in a market where rents or prices are moving — but the failure is a signal to look harder at the expenses.
Getting the rent right matters more than getting the price right. The rent a property can actually command is set by comparable rentals in the same area, not by what the seller says or what the mortgage needs. Check listings for similar homes nearby, and be careful with a seller's stated rent if the property is already tenanted: a below-market rent with a long lease is a cost, not a feature.
Step 2: Work out the real expenses
Gross rent is not income. The property's operating expenses come out first: property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance and repairs, property management fees where a manager is used, HOA dues where they apply, and an allowance for vacancies between tenants. A common planning shortcut is the 50% rule, which assumes operating expenses take about half the gross rent. It is a rough planning figure, not a measurement — the real share depends on the property's age, condition, taxes, and location — but it is a useful check against an expense estimate that looks too low.
Net operating income, or NOI, is the gross annual rent minus the operating expenses, before the mortgage payment. It is the property's income as a property, separate from how it is financed. Two properties with the same rent and price can have very different NOI if one has high taxes or an old roof, which is why the expense estimate is where most evaluations go wrong.
Step 3: The cap rate
The capitalisation rate, or cap rate, is NOI divided by the purchase price, expressed as a percentage. It answers one question: how much income does this property produce for each dollar of price, before financing? Because it ignores the mortgage, it lets properties be compared on equal terms regardless of how much is borrowed. A higher cap rate means more income relative to the price; a lower one usually means a more expensive market or a lower-risk property. There is no single good cap rate — the useful comparison is between similar properties in the same area.
Worked example: a $220,000 property renting for $1,800 a month. Gross annual rent is $1,800 × 12, or $21,600. Using the 50% rule as a planning assumption, operating expenses are $10,800, giving NOI of $10,800 and a cap rate of 4.91% ($10,800 divided by $220,000). With a tighter expense assumption of 40% of gross rent, NOI is $12,960 and the cap rate is 5.89%. Either way, the 1% rule fails: $1,800 is 0.82% of $220,000, not 1%. The Rental Property Cash Flow, Cap Rate & Cash-on-Cash ROI Calculator runs the same calculation from the property's actual expenses, so the cap rate comes from real figures rather than a rule of thumb.
Step 4: Monthly cash flow and cash-on-cash return
Cash flow is what remains after every monthly cost, including the mortgage. Monthly cash flow equals the rent minus the mortgage payment (principal and interest), property taxes, insurance, maintenance, management, and a vacancy allowance. If the result is positive, the property pays for itself each month; if it is negative, the owner covers the shortfall. Cash-on-cash return is the annual cash flow divided by the cash invested — the down payment plus closing costs — expressed as a percentage. It is the return on the money actually put in, which is the figure that matters to the buyer.
Use this calculator with clients → White-label.
Worked example, continued: the $220,000 property. Assume a 25% down payment of $55,000, a loan of $165,000 at an example rate of 7% over 30 years, and monthly costs of $250 for taxes, $150 for insurance, $150 for maintenance, and $90 for vacancy. The principal-and-interest payment is $1,097.75 a month. Cash flow is $1,800 − $1,097.75 − $250 − $150 − $150 − $90, which is $62.25 a month, or $747 a year. Against the $55,000 down payment (closing costs not included in this simplified example), that is a cash-on-cash return of 1.36%. The property just about breaks even — and a single repair or a month of vacancy would turn it negative. The Rental Property Cash Flow, Cap Rate & Cash-on-Cash ROI Calculator reproduces this example and shows how the numbers change with a different price, rent, or rate.
Worked example: a $180,000 property renting for the same $1,800 a month. The 1% rule passes exactly: $1,800 is 1.00% of $180,000. Gross annual rent is still $21,600, and with the same 40% expense assumption, NOI is $12,960, giving a cap rate of 7.20%. With a 25% down payment of $45,000, the loan is $135,000, and the principal-and-interest payment at the same example rate of 7% over 30 years is $898.16 a month. With the same monthly costs of $250, $150, $150, and $90, cash flow is $1,800 − $898.16 − $640, which is $261.84 a month, or $3,142 a year — a cash-on-cash return of 6.98% on the $45,000 down payment. The same rent on a $40,000 cheaper property changes the result from marginal to clearly positive, which is why the price matters more than the rent.
What the numbers do not show
Three things matter that no formula captures. The first is the property's condition: an old roof, old plumbing, or a failing heating system turns into capital spending that the monthly expense allowance may not cover. The second is the neighbourhood: rents, vacancy, and tenant demand vary street by street, and a property's numbers depend on them. The third is the financing: the examples above use a 7% rate as an assumption, and the Mortgage Calculator shows how the payment — and therefore the cash flow — moves with the rate. A property that cash-flows at one rate may not at another. The House Affordability Calculator is the place to test whether the purchase price fits the buyer's overall finances before the rental numbers are run at all. For the full picture of mortgage costs behind these examples, see The Complete Guide to Mortgage Costs and Home Buying.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good cap rate for a rental property?
There is no single good cap rate, because it varies by market, property type, and risk. A higher cap rate means more net operating income relative to the price, and a lower cap rate usually means a more expensive market or a lower-risk property. The useful comparison is between similar properties in the same area, not against a fixed number.
What is the 1% rule for rental properties?
The 1% rule is a screening rule of thumb: the monthly rent should be at least 1% of the purchase price. On a $200,000 property, that means $2,000 a month in rent. It is a quick filter for whether a property is worth a closer look, not a guarantee of cash flow — a property that passes still needs a full cash flow check.
How do I calculate cash flow on a rental property?
Monthly cash flow is the rent minus all monthly costs: the mortgage payment (principal and interest), property taxes, insurance, maintenance, property management if used, and an allowance for vacancies. If the result is positive, the property pays for itself each month; if it is negative, the owner covers the shortfall. A rental property ROI calculator runs the same calculation from the price, rent, and expenses.
What expenses should I include when evaluating a rental property?
Include the mortgage payment, property taxes, homeowners insurance, maintenance and repairs, property management fees if you use a manager, HOA dues where they apply, and an allowance for vacancies between tenants. A common planning shortcut is the 50% rule, which assumes operating expenses take about half the gross rent, but the real figure depends on the property's age, condition, and location.
