LLC vs S-Corp
An LLC and an S-corp are not the same kind of thing, and that causes most of the confusion. An LLC is a legal structure; an S-corp is a tax election. Here is how they differ and how to choose.
An LLC is a structure, an S-corp is a tax choice
The first thing to understand is that LLC and S-corp are different categories. An LLC, or limited liability company, is a legal structure created under state law. It separates your personal assets from your business, so a business debt or lawsuit does not normally reach your house or your savings. An S-corp, short for S corporation, is not a legal structure at all: it is a tax election a business makes with the IRS, choosing to be taxed under the rules for S corporations.
That means the choice is not really LLC or S-corp. It is whether to form an LLC, a corporation, or another structure — and then, separately, whether to elect S-corp tax treatment. An LLC can elect to be taxed as an S-corp. A corporation can also elect S-corp status. Many small businesses start as an LLC and later make the S-corp election when it starts to make financial sense.
By default, a single-owner LLC is taxed as a sole proprietorship: the business income is reported on the owner’s personal tax return, and the owner pays self-employment tax on the profits. A multi-owner LLC is taxed as a partnership by default, with the same pass-through idea: the business itself does not pay income tax, the owners do. An S-corp is also a pass-through in the sense that business income flows to the owners’ returns, but the mechanics are different.
How the tax treatment differs
The main difference people care about is self-employment tax. In a default LLC, the owner pays self-employment tax on the business profits. In an S-corp, the owner is an employee of the business and must be paid a reasonable salary, which is subject to payroll taxes. Profits above that salary can be taken as distributions, which are not subject to self-employment tax. That difference is the reason many profitable businesses make the S-corp election: once profits are well above a reasonable salary, the tax saving can be significant.
But the S-corp route comes with more work. The business has to run payroll, file payroll tax returns, and keep more formal records. The owner has to decide what a reasonable salary is, and the IRS can challenge a salary that is set too low. There are also limits: an S-corp cannot have more than 100 shareholders, all of whom must generally be US individuals or certain trusts, and it can only issue one class of stock. An LLC has none of those limits.
So the usual advice is to start simple and switch when the numbers justify it. A new or small business often starts as an LLC with default taxation, because it is cheap to set up and simple to run. When the business is earning a steady profit comfortably above what a reasonable salary would be, the S-corp election starts to pay for its extra paperwork. The exact point depends on your income, your state, and your situation, so talk to a tax professional before electing S-corp status — the wrong choice can cost more than it saves.
Frequently asked questions
Is an S-corp the same thing as an LLC?
No. An LLC is a legal business structure created under state law. An S-corp is a tax election made with the IRS. An LLC can elect to be taxed as an S-corp, and a corporation can too.
Why do businesses elect S-corp status?
Mainly for self-employment tax. In an S-corp, the owner is paid a salary subject to payroll taxes, and profits above that salary can be taken as distributions that are not subject to self-employment tax. The saving is only worth it once profits are well above a reasonable salary.
What are the downsides of an S-corp?
More paperwork and cost: payroll, payroll tax filings, and more formal records. There are also limits — no more than 100 shareholders, generally all US individuals, and only one class of stock. The IRS can also challenge a salary set too low.
